Paul did a video where he showed how easy it was to use the rotary, and how it was simple to hit the 2 and 4 positions. Two things hit me while I watched it - one, that I was much gentler on the rotary than he was. he was pretty much slamming it where it needed to go.
Two, I felt like I had the look on my face that sometimes people get when I'm explaining how I do something, and I realize that they clearly don't see the situation the same way I do. Paul said hitting the 2 and 4 was easy - you just flip it to 1 or 5, then back one spot. It seemed pretty clear that he thought that was just the obvious solution and clearly the best way. I would have never considered doing it that way - and I never quite got the hang of changing it that quickly.
Just goes to show that we all see things differently at times. Me, I like the 5-way rotary. But it's not the easiest thing to use, especially for quick switches, so that's partly why I got the 3-way toggle on my PS.