I've really loved using the HFS pickup in a solid mahogany body(McCarty, in my case) for heavier rock tones. For the last couple years, I've really been liking the 5708 and 5909 pickups for those same tones. Now, I have multiple guitars to be able to keep guitars with both, but, I really have a hard time choosing what I want to use in rehearsals and for gigs. I guess there are worse problems to have. What's a guy to do???:biggrin: Neck pickup, I've pretty much decided the 5708 is my favorite pickup with the 5909 close behind. I could change my neck pickup in every guitar and not think twice about it. How have your tastes changed over time? How do you deal with those changes...binge and purge everything to new taste, just buy more gear so you have it all?