A vote for the SC250. I still have my les Paul but recently bought the S2 SC250. If coming from an eclipse the sc250 will feel very similar IMO. I've had an eclipse. The Sc250 is a nice, lighter weight than the average les Paul but has a nice bite about it. Hard to explain but sounds a cross between a les Paul and an sg to my ears. I know what you mean about a les Paul. They can sound a bit boomy and muddy after a while. ive had mine for a couple of weeks now and just love it. Sounds great in the mix. Just my 2 pennies worth (yes, from the uk).