594 tuner question
- Thread starter ChesterB
- Start date
Warmart
Fani PRSi
Yes, starting with 2020. And you can replace with phase 3 locking tuners yourself.
RickP
Established 1960, Still Not Dead
Seems more a consistency across the 2020 line thing. P3 tuners were designed to transfer the tone, and (not to be too obvious) have the upgrade of locking from the old style tuners. Personally, I see it as a step backwards to something that was left behind for good reason decades ago and runs contrary to “the best of vintage guitars without the vintage problems” concept. Not a total deal-breaker, for certain, but a move I really don’t understand.
Last edited:
dmatthews
Dave's not here
I have a 2001 McRosie with vintage tuners.
I prefer the phase III locking tuners, but the vintage work perfectly.
I prefer the phase III locking tuners, but the vintage work perfectly.
Warmart
Fani PRSi
Whenever my durn boat sells, I'm getting a 594 - in that there is no doubt. If I luck upon a 2020, I'm definitely going to be leaning towards a tuner replacement. I haven't had to wrap for years, and I don't wanna go back.
Ovibos
Naughty Wood Librarian
I'm just not a fan of the vintage skinny stem with plasticy buttons.
Warmart
Fani PRSi
And neither am I.
RickP
Established 1960, Still Not Dead
Me three. A rare bad idea. I don't know how many holes I've poked in my fingers while twisting strings around a tuning peg to lock them. To hell with going back to that.
dcm_guitar
New Member
I'm in the same boat......DO WANT the TCI pickups. DO NOT WANT the vintage style tuners. Since I bought two high-end guitars in the last 6 weeks I'm in no danger of buying anything new right now............I think.
Andrew Paul
The cat's meow
My opinion switching to the vintage turners is a mistake. Phase III are awesome.
bodia
Authorities said.....best leave it.....unsolved
I'll put Phase III on mine. Too lazy to wrap and stretch strings! Perhaps I'll find a good one at Exp.
I’ve had enough PRSes with both kinds of tuners that I know it won’t matter to me when my 2020 McCarty arrives, since I basically hate all string changes, regardless of tuning machine type.
I drag out string changes until the strings are so dead they turn into flesh-eating zombies.
When I change strings, it always seems like a brand new experience, despite playing since 1967 (which was probably my last string change on my SG Special).
So, you know, go ahead and torture me once in a blue moon.
I drag out string changes until the strings are so dead they turn into flesh-eating zombies.
When I change strings, it always seems like a brand new experience, despite playing since 1967 (which was probably my last string change on my SG Special).
So, you know, go ahead and torture me once in a blue moon.
jxe
babe en der wood
could not agree more, gentlemen don’t break strings.
I’ve had enough PRSes with both kinds of tuners that I know it won’t matter to me when my 2020 McCarty arrives, since I basically hate all string changes, regardless of tuning machine type.
I drag out string changes until the strings are so dead they turn into flesh-eating zombies.
When I change strings, it always seems like a brand new experience, despite playing since 1967 (which was probably my last string change on my SG Special).
So, you know, go ahead and torture me once in a blue moon.
Bluesverb
Currently in a long term relationship with myself!
Regardless of the reasons, they are cheaper tuners and will be advertised as a look/tone improvement. The locking tuners are superior. Remember? Remember when they were advertised as a tone enhancement? As of late, I have been so hesitant of all the "tone" improvements, especially taking the chrome off the tuning pegs. The prices have climbed significantly over the last 5 years and it just seems that people (myself included) get lost in some obscure detail that can't be measured let alone discerned by the human ear. However, if someone says the tuners are better, then people automatically believe it. Sorry, but having been in manufacturing and involved with various projects, non-chromed tuning pegs was the turning point for me personally. For example, the V12 finish? Where are we with that?
I personally believe we can't be "yes" men/women. We have to give feedback, albeit positive or negative.
I personally believe we can't be "yes" men/women. We have to give feedback, albeit positive or negative.
BrianC
more toys than talent
The trend with "the kids" these days is Vintage is Better. Look at Tele's making a big come back. I am sure that Nitro, Vintage tuners and other Retro moves will help sell more....
jxe
babe en der wood
Andrew Paul
The cat's meow
RickP
Established 1960, Still Not Dead
Love my SS. Those grey Teisco Del Ray-esque tuner buttons are the only cheap looking part on an otherwise pretty guitar. Work great, just homely. But even on a ‘63.5 era guitar... locking tuners (on my ‘18 model anyway). I don’t buy it.
Similar threads
