I have indeed had the opportunity to compare a few "side-by-side". More than a Baker's Dozen of DC's against a Holy-Grail Private Stock SC 594 Prototype.
The Doublecut's DEFINITELY are more ergonomically friendly, thinner, on average lighter, also more compact - meaning your left hand is closer into your body. I love that about them, having been gigging the DC 245 for 7 years, and the DC 594 feels very similar in that regard, but better to me as I like the scale length A LOT better! 3/32" of an inch doesn't sound like a lot, but holy cow is it different, at least for me.
Definitely easier access to the upper frets as well.
Thanks for that response Pete, that seems to confirm my subconscious tendencies as well.
I've owned about 5 custom 24's Some SE's but I never could quite bond with, But the Mark Tremonti signature.
I Completely and totally bonded with it, just something about it, which I suspect has a lot to do with the LP shape and construction. I did put a pearly gates humbucker in it, which got it deep into the 59 LP Territory. its very satisfying extremely Fun to play. therapy. So I wanted to go deeper into Les Paul territory I bought 2014 classic Gibson Les Paul which weighs in at 10.4 pounds(No weight relief) it's so interesting I put the exact same Pearly Gates pickup into it and it seems to have more thunder in the power chords and yet has a little more sparkle in the top end. So I was worried a little bit about buying the double cut, I think your confirming that I need that mysterious something that the single cut offers. Although I'm getting tired of picking up that 10 1/2 pound monster. The Tremonti weighs in at 9.0 lb and is 99% the equal of the Les Paul tone wise But of course the tremolo makes the guitar twice as flexible. But since the Tremontis's pickups are situated higher up from the bridge it seems to be missing some of that top-end (maybe hi mids) sparkle that the Les Paul offers. So I think I'm leaning towards the 9.5 pounds SC 594, I also think I would like the full turn version of the 58/15, Or even a 59/09, The pearly gates is based on the 59 humbucker that Billy Gibbons has in his 59 Les Paul. I really love that pickup both of my guitars are now Very vintage And rude at the same time, And I can't stop playing them when I pick them up. I think the single cut 594 will fit right in between those 2 guitars, I'm hoping it matches the Les Paul tones with the more athletic weight. my next concern is the LT versions will that satisfy me since I love the pearly gates so much.
I have a feeling that an overdrive pedal is enough to make the LT's completely satisfying.
Thanks again I'm also based in San Francisco area, I see that you travel around all the time let me know if you're passing by this way, & chat about guitars as therapy.
Yes, you nailed what I would say, Basauri!
I love my SC 594, but the DC 594 would be my primary gigging guitar if I were playing out right now, and also if I could one have one guitar, it would be the DC, no question.
Thankfully, I am able to have more than one!! (Whew!)
I agree Les, there is just something satisfying about them, something subtly different than their Doublecut counterparts. That was the case for the DC and SC 245's, and translates through for me with the DC and SC 594's.
I can't explain it either, but I do believe a key part is the difference of the body being attached to the neck very differently, as Les mentions above. I believe more so
that than the weight or the thickness.
With my years of collecting many fine examples of very similar DC and SC PRSi in many subtle variations, I have also really come to appreciate how a guitar "feels", which to me is how it feels as it resonates under your fingers, in hands and arms, and into your body, and how that connects to what comes out in tone. The SC's feel different than the DC's, very much so. Korina feels different than Mahogany. My new Semi-Hollow feels markedly different than a Solidbody. (And man, I *LOVE* the new Semi-Hollow, WOW!!) Even within Core and WL 594's they all feel a little different.
That brings me back full circle to Ironwolf's comment about weight. For the many DC 594's I have owned, I have found the ones that weighed between about 8 pounds 3 ounces to 8 pounds 6 ounces to feel and sound the best, or at least feel the best. That was freaked me out a bit how consistently that was the case. The lighter ones all felt GREAT on a strap ergonomically of course, but the feel of the resonance of the guitar just felt "right" in that 8.5 pounds give or take range. And I have learned that that "feel" is just as important to me as the tone, and has a big impact of which ones end up being keepers and which ones do not.
The SC 594 is 8 pounds, 9.6 ounces, and it feels "right" for what it is. The SC 594's on Reverb seem to all be in that range, give or take. I look forward to the possibility of sampling more SC 594's!
Of course my Semi-Hollow DC 594 feels and sounds terrific at 6 pounds, 15 ounces, which is truly magical!