Les, I understand and agree with everything you said above. That's why I like pedals with some tonal control. Into a bright amp, I may use the Timmy the exact opposite of how I use it now, for example. But your base line tone, and then what you want when you do kick the pedal on may be completely different from mine, and what I'm after. So totally get that when discussing this stuff.
Andy uses a Custom 50 a lot, which I had and sold (probably should not have, but did get the Bogner in trade). That amp has a lot of mids and bottom like the Archon does so even though the Archon has more gain, I found that similar pedals worked well with both when I had both. Further, the pedals would be dialed similarly with both... again, Timmy boosting treble and cutting bass for a solo boost, with some gain and some level boost as well.
I quoted the line above to say, first, thank you again for the kind remarks. And second, I'm still not really sure I have A tone. I still change things literally every time I turn an amp on. For example: The last 3 times I played the Bogner, I had it in 70s mode, but last night played it for over an hour in 80s mode. I played the Archon twice last week. One night with the gain never over 9:00 and one night with it at 11:00 (and any Archon owner will tell you, 9:00 is classic JCM800 type gain... maybe plus a little. 11:00 is another level... true high gain. I adjust the pedals to what I'm doing that night while I'm playing them, and go.
And lastly, I DO like to copy or get close, to some of the tones of the icons. If I play an Ozzie song, I want to sound like Randy or Zach or Jake. When I play a Van Halen song, I want something close to Eddies tone, etc. But if I had a gig tomorrow night of doing originals, I'm comfortable enough with all theses varying factors to pick a cab and set the Archon where I'd want it and that would be "my tone." It's just that when I'm playing lots of stuff, it never stays in one place for long.