The nice thing about tubes is that changing them is as easy as pie, so it's interesting to experiment. And, of course, as cool as that video is, it also shows the problem with A/B comparisons, in that by the time you're a few switches in, it becomes difficult to remember what you heard only seconds ago, and the differences are small enough to make things confusing.
There's really no substitute for longer-term experiments, where you play things for a few days at a time, see how they're sitting with what you do, instead of making short term quick judgments.
On a personal note, I've done a lot of tube swapping over the years, and have learned that if I like the sound of an amp stock, I often have better luck sticking with the original tube brands than I do switching them out, thereby changing a tone that I liked in the first place (which is why I bought the amp, duh!).
Of course, if I can make an
improvement, I'll go for that. So it never hurts to try different things, you can always go back.
I also do think that in general, NOS tubes have are often a reliability improvement, if not necessarily a sonic improvement, though some really do sound better in certain amps.
Funny thing about that video, Les, is that I like the opposite clips between rhythm and lead clips.
Admittedly the differences are subtle, but I tend to agree with you. And that might also come down to the preamp tubes that weren't part of the test, or simply how the amp is designed.