This is NOT a thread to argue about who's best. Everyone's better than everyone else for someone, it's a question of the music you like!
There are no wrong answers, and this will NOT be on the test! I have my favorites, and it's on me to share, so...here we go!
Greatest composer, all-time, all genres:
There are times I've been a texture person; there are times I've loved counterpoint; there are times I've gotten into sturm und drang, minimalism, baroque, medieval, and goodness knows what else. But at heart, I'm blown away by great melody and harmonic orchestration. I love a lot of orchestral music. I love great rock, great blues, great jazz, and great film composers.
But we're talking all-time greatness here, and for me there's only one favorite:
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky was, in a word, magic. His orchestration was incredible, it's true. But with Tchaikovsky it's the melodies, the melodies, and the melodies. Against the harmonic content they are unbelievable, every one better than the previous one. We've all heard warhorses like the Nutcracker Suite. Take another listen to the sophistication of the melodic content and the orchestration. No one's ever gotten it done better.
The poor guy died of typhus at the age of 53, and yet in his short lifetime produced work that's become part of the vernacular of great music.
When I listen to Tchaikovsky, I get so emotional that I get choked up and have to fight back tears. Yes, I know! I'm a big sissy, and so what! I don't care.
That's what great creative work does to me.
There are no wrong answers, and this will NOT be on the test! I have my favorites, and it's on me to share, so...here we go!
Greatest composer, all-time, all genres:
There are times I've been a texture person; there are times I've loved counterpoint; there are times I've gotten into sturm und drang, minimalism, baroque, medieval, and goodness knows what else. But at heart, I'm blown away by great melody and harmonic orchestration. I love a lot of orchestral music. I love great rock, great blues, great jazz, and great film composers.
But we're talking all-time greatness here, and for me there's only one favorite:
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky was, in a word, magic. His orchestration was incredible, it's true. But with Tchaikovsky it's the melodies, the melodies, and the melodies. Against the harmonic content they are unbelievable, every one better than the previous one. We've all heard warhorses like the Nutcracker Suite. Take another listen to the sophistication of the melodic content and the orchestration. No one's ever gotten it done better.
The poor guy died of typhus at the age of 53, and yet in his short lifetime produced work that's become part of the vernacular of great music.
When I listen to Tchaikovsky, I get so emotional that I get choked up and have to fight back tears. Yes, I know! I'm a big sissy, and so what! I don't care.
That's what great creative work does to me.