You don't like the Hall of Fame II?
A lot of greay guitarists use it.
Robben Ford for one.
I get it. It's an opinion thing. I just didn't like it. It was just so... I don't know... sterile and digital sounding, I guess. For me. I just thought it was funny that you said the amp needs a good pedalboard and then the reverb in question was one I had and really didn't like. It would be pretty funny if your chorus of choice was the Earthquaker Sea Machine because I really really really hated that one.
It wouldn't be fair to poo poo someone's reverb without throwing out there the
Walrus Slo (for textures, the gigging amp has spring reverb)
Deluxe Amplification 6g15 with tremolo
For the Moog:
Other ones laying around:
Red Panda Context
BYOC Spring Reverb
EQD Dispatch Master
I might actually have a reverb problem.