Update time...
I really like the folks at TGS - great guys and they know their stuff. Glad to hear you found one that works for you!
Glad you liked "my" guitar - I still weep over the trade in, but my back is happier. The rest of me will be happier when my Build is done!
I had a Stealth 2x12 cab with V30s for a while - great cab, just too much and overkill for my needs. The PRS V30 doesn't have the harshness most of them have.
Funny about the pickups - I love 57/08s, but not in the first guitar I tried with them. I had a C24 with 59/09s and I found them too shrill for my taste and I stayed away from them for a long time. Now thanks to Steve's ME SCT I'm back to being a fan again! Wonder if it's just that certain wood and spec combos fit different pickups better or simply my ears have changed (again?).
To resolve the question posed in the thread title, I'm delighted to report that the answer is a resounding: "to core". A couple solid hours spent test-driving took me back to the consistent result every time. I
do need a Custom 24. Thusly, a NGD should be imminent.
Once again, thanks to everyone who chimed in, I can't emphasize how helpful all the input was. It's a luxury to be able to discuss this sort of thing and get fresh eyes scrutinizing your ideas from the outside. Bomb!
Stuff I learned today:
-
The Guitar Store is purely awesome.
- I can indeed comfortably play pattern regular, and love it.
- I can't play pattern thin no matter what. Even during blind testing it got uncomfortable very quickly.
- Despite what my ears told me on two prior occasions, I now
really like 57/08s.
- Got to demo a V30 loaded PRS 2x12 cab for the first time (grr, in the shuffle I didn't get to note the model). Great response!
- While vastly beyond my chops or pay grade, that
PS ToL McCarty is now the single most exquisite instrument I've ever played. Wow.
More to come.