Hey Pete stunning incoming but i have to ask:
Do you feel like you had your fill from a certain guitar
And a bit tired of it's specific tone to move to the next or indeed
Order a new one or is it a matter of continuous rotation for your stable of guitars?
Or do each one satisfy a different part of your sensory buds
and make your body tingle in a different way?
Asking this since i've been following your 5 year journey with over 70 PRSi searching
For the ulitmate tone ( for you of course )
Hey there! Good question.
For me the DC 245 Ted is still my favorite PRS ever. It is "Home" for me. The way that model plays, sounds and feels, I just love. For playing out, that is my go-to model for sure. My 408-equipped 6 pound Obeche DC 245 is a killer gigging machine, sounds AMAZING, never hurts my back, and those 408 pickups are VERY versatile, that guitar really gives me all the sounds I need live. We play a diverse set of different types of songs, and I can get all the tones I need, mostly on rhythm, with some lead work. No effects except for Chorus and Clean boost, through a 2 Channel H and a PRS 4x10 cab. I like a simple and reliable setup.
The McCarty Singlecut is for me about the tone and the vibe. Whereas the DC 245 is a terrific combination of the ergonomics and a tone that slants towards as Les Paul'ish sound with the short scale, the MSC is all-in on the Les Paul formula. As stated before, it hits the "sounds in your head" thing, really nails those classic rock sounds delivered over the years from those 59 Les Pauls, both on the bridge pickup and those creamy leads on the neck. (That is where the 408's fall short IMO, is that creamy neck lead tone. The 408 neck pickup sounds amazing for a lot of great tones. But it does not have that LP creamy lead tone like a DC 245 with a 5708 or 5909 neck pickup, and this MSC totally gets that tone, more so than any of my Ted's.)
The DC 245 is "me", and the MSC is more so the classic tones in my head.
I do want to gig one of these at least once, just to experience it versus the DC 245's, but I don't think I will ever go away from the DC 245 Ted's being my favorite. Remember I strayed from DC Ted's before, and ended up coming right back. I did the Wood Library DGT, McCarty Shootout, the SC 58's, and ultimately wasn't satisfied until I returned to the DC Ted's. The Glacier Blue one Aristotle now has was my favorite of the Wood Library ones, followed by the Solana one, they were all so great. And then I took it up a notch and built these two amazing DC 245 PS Ted's (and a couple more that are no longer around).
I am having fun with this model right now, but my longer term plan still centers around the DC 245 Ted, I still have a list of DC 245 creations I want to make, which include a DC 245 Trem (looking forward to playing Alan's when his comes in) and a DC 245 with the two piece bridge. I just got a little distracted here along the way...
All in due time, something to look forward to!