This thread is full of amazing examples of why there is, IMHO, no one set answer to the question.
The best color? Or best finish utilizing multiple colors? If just one "color" across the whole top, no bursts, no fades, but we allow multiple stain phases using different stain colors, I would say Northern Lights. Does PRS do any finish using just a single stain color for the whole top? i.e. is Emerald Green just a particular dark-ish green stain? Or is there always some magic of first layer with a dark stain like black/gray, sanded down a bit, then another stain as primary "color" that is perceived, maybe a third for highlights? Seems like all the videos I have seen have involved multiple stain steps. Maybe Blue Matteo is a single stain step?
If we can do bursts/fades/glows/etc:
I would posit one of the Dragon's Breath versions, or the Beach Fade (at the angle, on quilt).
And as
@11top said (and
@LSchefman concurred with):
It depends upon the wood. While I’d choose natural as a gun to the head default “color”, if I’m going to paint it, my choice would change for fiddleback vrs quilt, vrs burl Maple. Also, who’s going to paint ziracote, macassar ebony, or cocobolo?
I like straight up non-burst stains on tight flames. But I also like fades on pretty well any figuring, especially fades between neighboring colors in the rainbow (e.g. red-yellow with orange in between, or blue-green). And after disliking the finish for a while because the orange "burst" looked too strong in dealer photos, I found a more-subtle Burnt Maple Leaf that I totally fell in love with via the SSH I snagged at Exp 2018.
Other bursts range from "looks great" to "looks classic, but not for me right now" to "nah, too harsh a contrast".
So glad I could offer such ambiguous conclusions...