Hmmm, I didn't have any issues with the 85/15's. I just found them way too bright and trebley. But I could still dial them in to a pretty sweet spot. I think they are great pick ups. But I had heard so much about the 58/15LT's, and what they were built to emulate, more of a classic PAF sounding pick up, and I thought they would be more for me. And they are. I find them way warmer, but still with ample brightness. I have heard some say they are kind of dark sounding, But I didn't find that at all. I think it also depends on what you play through. My amp is a '71 Fender twin. The 58/15LT's sound amazing through that and it's a perfect combo, imo.