Well, no. Not true. Not even remotely true. Playing (and recording) with tone is my specialty and my livelihood, and I know different.
While it’s just fine to go straight into the amp, the result is
different, not somehow “better.”
I’d argue with you about what you said about Blackface Deluxes, amps that were used to lay down some amazing classic blues and rock sounds, but that’s a taste thing. You’re entitled to your opinion.
You drive a tube amp with solid state pedals, and of course you’re altering the guitar signal with the pedal, but the tubes and other parts of the amp
still add their coloration to the sound coming out of the speaker,
just as they add coloration when you don’t use pedals.
If you can duplicate the tones that I got on this piece where I used a chain of about half a dozen pedals into my HXDA, with your solid state amp, I’ll buy you a beer.
NOTE: I’m not posting my track because I think I’m so awesome; I’m posting it because I know exactly how I got those tones, from guitar settings, to pedals and pedal settings, to cables, to amp settings, to recording chain. Everything matters. Every link in that chain resulted in changes in the tone. Since I know exactly what I did, I can share the info with you, and you can try to duplicate the sound with your solid state amp.
Throw down, record the result, and let’s see how well your claim can be backed up! Here’s my track:
https://soundcloud.com/lschefman/pedaland-4
Or better yet, try to get those tones with just guitar, amp and cable, without pedals. You won’t be able to do that, either. I’ll buy you a second beer if you can.
Folks who set an amp clean and try to get all their sounds with pedals (I don’t work that way) can still benefit from what tubes do to a degree, but when pedals are set just right, and the amp is set to react to the input with any level of distortion, you get a unique sound that a solid state amp will not create in the same way. That’s just a simple fact.
And it’s been attested to since the first pedals ran into the first tube amps (I’ve been playing since the late 60s), over and over again by an awful lot of great players. I’m not going to recount them, the evidence has been all over records and the airwaves for over 50 years.