Oh boy... 2 McCartys incoming - update on page 2

Family Man

New Member
Joined
Feb 21, 2022
Messages
63
The PRS bug bit me recently, and I ordered an S2 McCarty 594 Thinline shortly after selling a very nice Gibson. Then I got to looking around more, and, well... I guess my impulses got the better of me. A 2002 McCarty (not all stock) is also on the way. :oops:

I'll most likely end up selling one or two more guitars to replenish the checking account, but I'm going to have a lot of fun with the "tryouts" to see which ones will stay.

aYuWwiF.jpg


ZxekEee.jpg
 
Thanks, guys. Shortly after ordering the S2, I came across that '02 and knew I was in trouble. I am a sucker for subtle flame, mineral streaks, and tasteful burst finishes. That '02 is one of the prettiest guitars I've ever seen.

Over the next couple weeks I'm going to have to figure out if one of these will go. Or maybe a Tele or two. Or maybe that acoustic I rarely play... I'm blessed to have to make such a decision!
 
I'm also blessed to have 2 McCarty's

2001 (The undertaker will have to pry this from my cold dead hands)
50461641067_f004ed4802_k.jpg


2015
50461483806_13c4916dfb_k.jpg


If they play anything like mine then my advice is let the acoustic (unless it holds sentimental value) and maybe a tele (likewise unless sentimental) go.

Either way, beautiful guitars

May you play them in good health for many years to come (KEEP BOTH - Different sounds:p)
 
Last edited:
I'm also blessed to have 2 McCarty's

2001 (The undertaker will have to pry this from my cold dead hands)
50461641067_f004ed4802_k.jpg


2015
50461483806_13c4916dfb_k.jpg


If they play anything like mine then my advice is let the acoustic (unless it holds sentimental value) and maybe a tele (likewise unless sentimental)

Either way, beautiful guitars

May you play them in good health for many years to come (KEEP BOTH - Different sounds:p)
Beautiful guitars you have there!

We'll see what happens. I just played the Tele I had in mind to potentially sell and it just surprises me every time with how good it sounds and how well it plays. It's going to be tough to let any guitar go at this point, but time will tell!
 
Last edited:
Thinline just arrived. I haven't bought a guitar in a while. What's the protocol when it's below freezing outside? Let it sit in the box a few hours inside before opening?
 
I would for sure. I've seen guys pull their instruments out of the case after riding in a cold trunk at 30 below and let them sit for just a few minutes before playing, but I sure don't recommend it. I won't leave my guitar(s) in a vehicle during the winter for any length of time, I will always find a way to get them inside. I let them adjust in the case (or a shipping box) for at least an hour depending on outside temps before exposing them to room temperature. There's condensation factors to consider too, both for the wood and electronics.
 
I was able to get the Thinline out, look it over, and play it for about 25 minutes on my lunch break. I haven't spent a bunch of time with it, but here are few first impressions:

1. I need to work on my setup abilities. This guitar plays better out of the box than all but one of my guitars at home.

2. The fit, finish, and feel are stellar from what I've been able to tell so far. The pots spin well and taper nicely. The switch is solid and I haven't heard any scratchy noises when switching pickups or adjusting volume/tone. The frets ends are slightly sharper than I remember them being on my S2 Mira, but are still stellar and better than any new Fender or Gibson I've ever seen/played. I have zero complaints about the finish work on this guitar.

3. The neck feels fantastic. Being a Pattern Thin, this was my biggest concern about getting along with the guitar. But with the wide nut, the neck is very comfortable to me.

4. The tuning stability is great. With my Fender and Gibson guitars, I'm used to having to make tuning tweaks while playing for 15-20 minutes after big temperature swings. It was something like 12 degrees here overnight. The guitar was still a little cold when I got it out of the gig bag. I tuned to pitch, and it remained there the whole time I played. I was actually kind of stunned it didn't go flat as it warmed up.

5. It sounds great! I like to play a lot of Gov't Mule, classic rock, southern rock, harder blues, etc. and this guitar nails that sound through my rig right out of the box.

6. I'm glad I went with the Vintage Mahogany finish. I originally ordered the Walnut finish, but later asked the store to swap it with the Vintage Mahogany model. Depending on the lighting, this finish can go from appearing dark, dark brown to a gorgeous light brown with all the mahogany showing through. The Walnut finish is much darker and I don't think the wood could really be seen in most lighting situations.

7. If I have one concern, it's that the 11th fret note on the B string didn't seem to ring out for me like all the others on the fretboard. I'm not saying it's a dead spot yet, because it still did ring, just not with the same sweetness and sustain as the rest of the fretboard. Could potentially be a little high spot on the 12th fret or something. I'll have to investigate further there.

In all, the Thinline seems to be a winner!

Oh, and it weighs 7lb 0.5oz for whatever that is worth.

Sorry for the photo quality. I'm definitely not a pro.

ITm9Hn5.jpg


RRa2kxO.jpg



yCD1YRG.jpg


VEIEedC.jpg
 
Last edited:
Screams class! FYI, if a guitar ships from or to a cold environment (or even passes through a cold environment like airplane cargo hold), the general rule is DO NOT OPEN FOR 24 HOURS!! Some sellers notify you of this and may even void your warranty if you do not abide by such limits!!! The biggest problem from what I have heard is, the finish can crack ;~(( You are lucky that you did not have this problem, but be aware of this going forward ;~)) Congrats on the new toy and enjoy enjoy enjoy!!!
 
Back
Top