I'm going to sway from the popular vote here...
I can absolutely appreciate the carve detail of an older CE, but for me, the satin neck was the deciding factor.
It just felt right. Super easy to play, and my hand feels like it just glides effortlessly on the satin neck.
Like the OP mentioned; I also was not a fan of the bare maple color on the CE neck.
And then I saw the satin black neck version... Sold. I bought mine, the day I saw it.
Looked great, felt great, played great, and sounded great.
As mentioned in a previous post; the only shortfall for the new CE, is the Korean bridge.
I swapped mine for a Mann 2000NOS, and it made a dramatic improvement to the sound and sustain.
https://forums.prsguitars.com/threads/2000nos-upgrade-and-a-few-other-mods.28321/