Cool, glad the gig went good. It's sometimes frustrating to use other people gear.
Tuner- I like the Poly Tune Mini or Korg Pitch Black for gigs. Haven't used the Korg in awhile.
Phaser - MXR Phase 90. There's tons of newer, crazier, fancier phasers...but the 90 is a classic. Run this pedal in front of the amp for most dramatic effect.
Delay - need more input from what you want on this. More vintage or modern? The Strymon Timeline is the do it pretty damn well pedal. Really pricey though. You could pick up a used Eventide Timefactor which is also awesome.
-Vintage types: I want a Catalinbread Belle Epoch bad, also the Wampler Faux Tape echo sounds good
....kind of in between is the Lovepedal Echophonic which is vintage-esque but not as dark sounding and very in expensive.
I just ran across the Earthquaker Devices Dispatch Master which look really cool too.
Depends a lot on how much flexibility you want/need.