Now that I’ve had more time with it, this one appears to have more bass compared to pernie, and the response appears more ‘even’ compared to many of my pernie axes. Gosh I sure hope I know what the heck I’m talking about. Paul’s probably laughing if he read this.
BTW I analyse these things purely unplugged, because the way strings vibrate sitting on a particular guitar is to me the basic unbreakable fundamental. I see pickups as expendable translators to that fundamental. For me a good pickup is simply one that translates accurately, capturing every accent and tic, not leaving out any nuance but at the same time not adding its ‘own interpretation’.
“Just tell me plainly what the dude with the strange hairdo is saying, man! Peace in the nuclear age depends on it!”
The woody tone is quite pronounced - kinda like slightly pinching your nose and saying “wah wah wah”. Super resonant and alive, and I mean it above the usual cliche. A very solid stiff feel to the whole guitar, feels like its weapons grade or something.
Based on this sample size of one I would recklessly give the thumbs up to Chaltecoco! But Paul chose the woods so I suppose that 30-40 years of experience would have factored regardless what woods species he picked. I personally believe tone tapping is real and works, or is at least the closest and most efficient tool mankind has at predicting stringed instrument tone. I’m very impressed, for that matter.