It was back in about 1989. I was in a local music store where my friend worked, and they had one PRS in stock, a black CE-24. Now, I'd never played a PRS before (probably on purpose, too, since I was hesitant because of the appreciable cost for me at the time), but I gave it a go. I only recall that I really liked it (a lot); it was built so nicely, and I especially liked that it felt like a definite step up from what I'd been using at the time (a really nice Ibanez Roadstar and a Washburn Explorer type. I had also had a couple of nice Les Pauls and Strats by then.)
Anyway, I was almost thinking of buying this black CE-24, but my friend told me to hold on... that their other store was due to get about a dozen other PRSes that very Friday. So alerted, I waited until that day and went over the their main store with my wonderful (and way too supportive) wife. Yes, there were about a dozen brand new PRSes hanging in a row, fresh out of their cases. Gorgeous. Honestly, I don't recall all the models, however, I do recall their prices, ranging from $899 up to near $3K (GULP). Oh, well. Time to dive in, but how could I really be sure?
Here's the part I like to remember: First, I set up an amp with a typical tone I would use (I'm thinking it would have been a Peavey Bandit at the time—not a bad amp at all), I sat down on a stool, and then... I closed my eyes for about a half hour. (I wanted to do this right! There was no way I wanted to be influenced by their looks or price tag, only their tone and playability.) At that point, with my friend checking the tuning of each guitar before I would play it and with my wife carefully putting each one into my hands, I would give each guitar a somewhat decent go for usually at least a couple of minutes, sometimes longer. And, no, I really didn't peek!
Anyway, I got that dozen down to my favorite three (groaning because they were ALL really nice), and then I went through the process all over again with only those three, finally picking my favorite out by an edge. At that point, my eyes were still closed, and, OMG, I was SO scared that I'd picked a $2,500 guitar "with birds and all", but the winner was... a beautiful CE-24 with a lovely tortoise shell/root beer flamed maple top and pearly dots. I was also SO relieved to discover that it was "only" ticketed at $1099. PHEW. Really, with that flamed top, it looked a whole lot more expensive than its tag (the only cheaper one there being yet another black CE-24). So, in the end, I had picked a wonderful bolt-on CE, and I do think that that specific design must have played a part in my choice without my being aware, being relatively unschooled at the time, and for years, I really couldn't find another PRS that I preferred. (Ahem. I have since corrected that several times over with some other equally nice PRSes.)
I still have that guitar, albeit recently modded with a 3-way toggle and a pair of Thornbuckers, which I have come to prefer to the HFS/VB pickups after a couple of decades. (I still have all the original parts.)
Oh, yeah. And my wonderful wife is STILL way too supportive of my guitar obsession...