Any theories on how the amazing single-coil pick-ups and the sweet HB pick-up would sound on a maple-topped guitar? My S2 Studio is the most Strat-like guitar I own, and the HB has amazing clarity bit is never harsh. How much does the all-hog body impact the tone?
I would expect there to be a small amount of added brightness and snap/attack to the notes, but not excessively so, certainly not to the point that the pickups wouldn’t jive.
The S2 Studio is about as fat sounding as I would dare push that kind of guitar - and I like it that way - very fat sounding and with some brightness, but not enough to be harsh. But there’s a balance there, to get those single coil tones, you just don’t want things to get muffled, the S2 Studio hits the sweet spot of getting as warm and fat as possible without going too far. I wouldn’t hesitate for a second to have one made with a maple top, if you’re concerned about not being harsh, thin, bright, whatever you want to call it, you still wouldn’t be in the neighborhood of something like a strat. Now, if you put a maple neck on there, that could get a little too snappy and bright, for some people - I totally get it, I’m not big on maple necks and bright guitars. Personally, I wouldn’t expect a ton of difference from a tonal perspective, and not sure paying the dough for a PS would be worth it from the standpoint of having a different tool, but that’s totally up to you.
I wonder if PRS pulled the plug prematurely on the S2 Studio. They were a limited run, but went on for a while, the run may have been extended due to their popularity. Even so, I think they could keep on selling plenty. Of course, they have the sales data and I don’t, so I can’t say for sure. With the in-between positions like a strat, yet different from tone of the Silver Sky, they itch a scratch that nothing else in the S2 line does, and they’re just so dang good.
If I was on a moderate budget and could only have one guitar, it may just be an S2 Studio. I may swap the bridge pickup out for a 57/08 in the name of versatility, the Starla pickup is certainly great for what it does, lots of chime and less mid push, which compliments the singles very nicely, but won’t growl as much as a PAF type. That being said, having multiple guitars, I have no desire to change it out.