Thanks for the input! I put in an order for the 59/09's. I figured I might be best served by going with the middle ground considering that lately I've been branching out to a lot more than heavy riffs and crunchy tones.
Do let us know how they sound when you get them installed. Always nice to hear about pup upgrades and whether they met/exceeded expectations.
On another note, I did a google search and found posts similar to this one...for some reason my post search within the forum didn't produce the same results. Sorry for stacking the forum with redundant threads!
The forum search automatically parses out terms it considers "too common", and also does not do a good job of finding the desired "string" within a longer one. For example, if you do an advanced search for "59/09" (without the quotes) in just Titles, this thread doesn't show up (in fact, no threads show up) - not sure why, possibly due to the slash. It won't let you search for "59" because that is too short of a search word.
Google on the other hand is far better at doing such things. There is a technique for searching specific forums on Google to effectively get around the actual forum's limitations. I think one good way is to add this to your Google search, for PRS Forum searches:
[noparse]
inurl

rsguitars.com/forum
[/noparse]
For example, Googling the following had pretty useful results:
[noparse]
inurl

rsguitars.com/forum 59/09
[/noparse]
I'm sure there are other refinements that could be made.
EDIT: btw, what a pain to figure out how to avoid the forum software from interpreting colon-p combos as a smiley instead of part of the inurl function...