sergiodeblanc
New Member
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2012
- Messages
- 27,380
Some people just have it, and others don’t.
And that’s why you and I are on the right side of the Dave or Sammy debate.
Is Rod Stewart the greatest rock singer?
- Thread starter Clashcityrocker
- Start date
Some people just have it, and others don’t.
And that’s why you and I are on the right side of the Dave or Sammy debate.
Antmax
New Member
Big Bruce Dickinson and Freddy Mercury fan here. I guess it really depends on the kind of music and vocals you like best.
Shawn@PRS
yogi
Exactly!
Weird coincidence that I listened to the "Every Picture Tells A Story" CD on my home form work today...
Rod's not the greatest, but his voice is certainly unique. That's what makes any of the singers you all have listed "great" - their unique sound and style.
Not much love for Geddy Lee? Perhaps because his voice is "too" unique for some people?
No women? Janis Joplin? Grace Slick? Ann Wilson?
Rod's not the greatest, but his voice is certainly unique. That's what makes any of the singers you all have listed "great" - their unique sound and style.
Not much love for Geddy Lee? Perhaps because his voice is "too" unique for some people?
No women? Janis Joplin? Grace Slick? Ann Wilson?
Clashcityrocker
Curve Denier
- Joined
- Aug 9, 2016
- Messages
- 1,141
Jeff Buckley is a great singer.
bodia
Authorities said.....best leave it.....unsolved
dmatthews
Dave's not here
Lister
Playing guitar badly since the 70's...
Thank You! It's hard to believe how often Steve gets overlooked when best singers gets debated. Without a doubt he had a great set of pipes back in the day.
Sandy Denny was no slouch in the vocal department.
Jon Anderson should get a little love as well.
11top
Cousin Eddie's cousin
Sammy for sure!!
dmatthews
Dave's not here
Cuz they're Closer to the Heart?
Alnus Rubra
Loving nature’s wonders
bodia
Authorities said.....best leave it.....unsolved
Great Gazoo
New Member
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2019
- Messages
- 395
Has it gone this far without Rob Halford being mentioned?
PJ Harvey for the ladies (though Ann Wilson is tough to beat).
PJ Harvey for the ladies (though Ann Wilson is tough to beat).
SteelHorse
New Member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2015
- Messages
- 84
Rik Emmett. Not bad at guitar playing either.
Bill SAS 513
Just another old guy in a T-shirt
...Maybe Willie shoved an Ever-Lasting Gob Stopper into his ear too far?? But...in his early years, sure. (Geddy certainly was unique, if nothing else)
For me, No one beats Freddie...Later Geddy (after the early Led Zeppelin comparisons), Tommy Shaw, Bruce Dickinson, Steve Walsh (Kansas), Love Macca's voice, Rik Emmett, Shoot, there's so many!!!
For me, No one beats Freddie...Later Geddy (after the early Led Zeppelin comparisons), Tommy Shaw, Bruce Dickinson, Steve Walsh (Kansas), Love Macca's voice, Rik Emmett, Shoot, there's so many!!!
Last edited:
Alnus Rubra
Loving nature’s wonders
Has anyone mentioned Joe Elliott?
Bill SAS 513
Just another old guy in a T-shirt
Not by everyone...Just me...LOLOL (I grew up listening to my older siblings playing the Beatles, and I've heard the same thing about Rush for years, and I still love 'em both)
Keeps it interesting around here!!!
