I've had my McCarty for 13 yrs. I got it with a small ding in the top. It was a Dallas Guitar show guitar and who knows what knuckledragger did it. It got 2 bills knocked off the price and you can't even see it when you're playing it as the forearm covers it. But recently, while moving around with a guitar stand, I dropped it and I heard that sickening thunk when it fell into my McCarty. It cracked the finish right at the bottom of the treble bout on the scrape binding and left a small but almost invisible blemish. I was pretty bummed and as is my OCD way, I started rubbing, I waxed it, I did pretty much anything I could think of, I removed the rough edges, but it's still there and will be. It is basically one of those "only I know its there" kinda dings, but one none the less. More deadly is the wraparound tailpiece. Drop that bad boy on the top and you are going to get a deep ding. I've saved mine twice now by good reflex, but none the less, it tells a tale of the guitars life. This guitar has been pampered as I no longer play out, and in Hawaii, it's pretty hard to find partners or jammers so it stays home. All of my guitars have been on a stage at some point in their lives and all returned unscathed, All my dings are from home...;-)