Thanks for the reply - being a PAF fan you can probably assume I’m not into the brootz. The 85/15’s are loaded into the new CE’s. I agree there’s no substitute for playing them but I think it’s fair to ask for hands on experience from people who have used them, especially using my love of PAF’s, a very popular and well known style of pickup, as a baseline. If someone asked my impressions as a comparison, I could probably accurately give non-subjective tips like whether or not it has more or less bass treble mids etc than vintage type humbuckers and whether or not it drives the amp harder or not.
We agree that the most important way to know is to play them. And your question isn’t unfair; it’s just not likely to give you the info you’re seeking. I’ll give it my best shot, and perhaps others will agree or disagree.
One problem is that there are so many kinds of PAF style pickups out there, each nuanced in different ways. Even the originals were pretty variable back in the day. So I’m going to use my 57/08 equipped guitars as a PAF baseline. For me, the 57/08 is a wonderful sounding PAF with lots of clarity and a beautiful top end.
The 85/15s are brighter, with more prominent upper midrange and high frequency push. They’re also hotter. But they still retain a PAF flavor. The result is a crisp and lively pickup that’s nice and open sounding. But it isn’t harsh sounding; I’d call its brightness a kind of shimmer, as opposed to sounding overly bright or screechy. It has a nice balanced sound.
One cool thing about the 85/15 is that you can roll back the volume control on the guitar, and control the amp’s gain with it, without losing much high end. I never feel that I need to boost the high frequencies to compensate for rolling off the guitar volume. The pickup’s tone controls actually do something, at least on my guitar, which is a plus.
There’s nice clarity and sparkle.
The 85/15 in my CU24 is noticeably hotter and brighter, and thicker in the upper midrange than the 58/15 or 58/15 LT, which are more vintage-voiced PAF style pickups with something of a scooped midrange.
At the same amp settings I use with the 85/15s, I have to turn the 58/15 and its LT brother up higher.
I generally go for those tones that are on the edge of amplifier breakup, so that softer picking yields cleaner notes, and digging in causes the amp to just break up. Most of my playing is through single channel amps, and my style varies depending on the work I do, but left to my own devices it’s kind of bluesy.
My main amp with the CU24 is a Plexi-type PRS HXDA, a single channel amp. The guitar I have with that pickup is about perfect for it, because I can vary the clean vs snarl just with the guitar’s volume control, or by digging in.
I don’t use dirt pedals very often.
The guitar also mates up well with the PRS DG30, another single channel amp that I’d call a vintage style amp that has a beautiful breakup and an interesting voicing, and a Mesa Lone star that’s a little harder to control with guitar volume than my single channel amps. However, the 85/15s sound quite good on both its clean and dirty channels. I think the Mesa is just less touch-sensitive, which is neither good nor bad, it just is. But the Lone Star has its charms.
I haven’t gotten around to playing it through a recently acquired Mesa Fillmore as of yet.
In conclusion, it’s a nice all-rounder pickup that can handle lots of different jobs, and has a very good tone balance. I hope this info helps.