I thought about this on the same lines as the Song game. Here goes nothing: Someone lists a band (and this is the important part) from past/present and At Their Peak, who was bigger? For example, is/was Motley Crue bigger/better than Pearl Jam? Or was The Who bigger/better than Nirvana? The winner moves on, the next contender comes in. Remember, it isn't now - at their peak. Might help if we list the year we're talking about. Or the album name (cannot use greatest hits albums) I'll start: Motley Crue (1986) bigger/better than Pearl Jam (1992)? I think Motley Crue was better.