I feel the same way, Les. I like to hear how I sound playing through my different amps. I think it's exciting to have some variety. I still sound like me from amp to amp, but with subtle variations in my tone.
Exactly!
I think part of the reason the variations are subtle is that we tend to like a certain range of sounds and dial 'em in that way anyway. But one thing I will say that differentiates my amps, at least besides the differences in tone: each one of them "feels" different. They respond to the guitar differently.
So I may in fact sound pretty much the same through any one of them by the time the sound is picked up by the mic and sent to my DAW, but I play a little differently through each amp. I think that's a big reason why, for example, I like to do longer single note solos with the HXDA, but I prefer to play more rhythmic parts via the DG30, even if it's gained up. It responds to my picking in a certain way that I like for that kind of stuff, and the feel is different from the HXDA.
Same with the Mesa Lone Star, that feels really easy to play on power-chordy stuff, or certain kinds of cleans, because it's more compressed.
And some of the reasons I pick an amp for certain tones is what I'm trying to accomplish; the HXDA is very vocal, and very warm, almost a purr. The DG30 has a sound that reminds me of a different vowel combination, more of a diphthong. Whereas the Mesa almost has less personality, but feels like I'm pushing more against the note, which is sometimes a good thing.
Last night I was watching another Tim Pierce video - I'm addicted to Tim Pierce's videos even though I play like dog poop compared to him - and he was demonstrating his different amps, this time a Divided by Thirteen, a Matchless, a Wizard, a Diezel, and a couple others.
And it was pretty obvious that despite the sonic differences between these amps, once he gets going on a track, he sounds like himself, just with small variations as you say.
Still, looking around his studio you could see his PRS amps, his favorite Naylor, set up on their ends because he's literally out of space around his workstation, he's got them all hooked up and working, and on and on -- so many amps!
He's also got his pedalboard at his feet, and a zillion pedals just lying around the tables, all connected via a switch box from the heads into the cabs he keeps in his garage in a soundproof closet.
But he plugs his cable from his pedalboard into each head instead of using a switcher, something I found interesting. I don't know why he does that, maybe it's just to keep things less crazy? Maybe he thinks a switcher going into the amp will screw with his tone? Who knows.
All very interesting, nonetheless.