57/08 vs. 53/10 neck pickups

vchizzle

Zomb!e Nine, DFZ
Joined
Apr 28, 2012
Messages
8,355
Location
WI
Anyone played the in the same guitar, or at least the same model of guitar? Compare, contrast, discuss...GO!
 
I have, in a Stripped 58 and an SC58. The only difference, other than the pickups, is an important one, the SC58 has en ebony fingerboard, which does change a few things.

The 57/08 has a somewhat brighter tone, the 53/10 a somewhat warmer one. I'd take the 57/08 for most rock, and the 53/10 for bluesier or jazzier stuff.
 
I would have to agree with Les . Granted my 57/08 guitar is a stripper and my 53/10 guitar is a modern eagle but I can still tell a differance in the pickups. Personally I think the 57/08 breakup a little easier than the 53/10 and are brighter even considering the fact that my 57/08's are in a singlecut. The 53/10 has a more rounded sound compared to where I think the 57/08 cuts through a little more. Playing rock music I would definately go with the 57/08's over the 53/10's.
 
I would have to agree with Les . Granted my 57/08 guitar is a stripper and my 53/10 guitar is a modern eagle but I can still tell a differance in the pickups. Personally I think the 57/08 breakup a little easier than the 53/10 and are brighter even considering the fact that my 57/08's are in a singlecut. The 53/10 has a more rounded sound compared to where I think the 57/08 cuts through a little more. Playing rock music I would definately go with the 57/08's over the 53/10's.

You and I are hearing this exactly the same way. Rounded is a good way of describing it. The 53/10s are great pickups for what they do, however.
 
I have played both the 57/08's (Custom 22 Artist Pkg) and the 53/10's (P22 Experience 2012) in a relatively similarly confirgured guitar. Both guitars have a Mahogany body and Maple top & both have an Ebony fingerboard, although the P22's is Mexican Ebony. Both have fixed (non-tremolo) bridges. However, the neck wood is Maple on P22 Experience guitar and it is the usual Mahogany on the Custom 22. To my ears, I am hearing the same thing as everyone else - a bit more warmth on the 53/10's, although I think that perhaps it is brightened somewhat by the Maple in the neck of the P22, it does still sound warmer - very sweet tone. I also have an ME Quatro (53/10's), which has a Rosewood Neck and Fingerboard, but also a tremolo (which I believe scoops the sound a bit more than the fixed bridge) - this one is noticably warmer, and probably has the overall "sweetest" sound of the three. I think all three can be used to great effect for blues/jazz, but the MEQ wins overall for sweetness of tone in the clean through moderately overdriven range. The Custom 22, with the 57/08's would be the most rocking of the three, but I've put the MEQ through my Boogie Mark V on Channel 3 with a very tight metal tone I've been working on and I feel it would track as well, possibly the best of the three for a RHYTHM hard rock or metal tone. The Custom 22 would be better for lead, however. And through my PRS H Combo, the Custom 22 is noticeably the brightest. But we're discussing awesomeness on all levels by very small margins here...
 
Back
Top