Recently I've been gasing for an S-type guitar (a Silver Sky would be at the top of the list) so I listed my '07 McCarty on kijiji (Canadian Craig's list basically) . I've been offered a bunch of other guitars, an '88 1962 AVRI, an EJ strat a '91 Jeff Beck and a Nash S63. None of them appealed me enough to pull the trigger, they didn't want to add enough cash, or any in some cases. I then saw an ad for a Silver Sky in which he was open to trades. I messaged and the guy is interested. both our guitars are in near mint shape. I bought the McCarty used, so I have no idea what they went for retail in 2007. I know today's McCarty is 4900$ CAD vs the Silver Sky at 2900$ CAD but I know retail doesn't always equate to the used market. My question is, do you think it's a fair straight up trade?