I've done a couple of youtube videos in the past on drum plugins and i've tried many of them.
Take into account I like big sounding drums and smooth kicks with power but not sub woofing power. Arena rock style I guess. Snares that really punch and reverberate. Tight kicks. smashing cymbals.
To summarise my experience.
Studio Drummer - Best out of the box sound, great interface and quality effects, no full song midi loops, could be considered expensive.
Native Instrument Drummer series - includes 60s,70s,80s,Modern Drummer - great sounds that really capture the decades, easy to use, 60s sounds great with acoustic style tracks, no full song format loops, Best to buy as a bundle in Komplete.
Addictive Drums - Best loop library which includes full song format for jam sessions, tweakable to the extreme. Can sound very real , great interface, great price.
Steven Slate Drums - Poor cymbals but amazing kicks, good snares, can sound synthetic, "mix ready" ,Poor user interface, all but forgotten by Slate Digital.
EZ Drummer - I remember this being really bad but i'm not qualified to say as it was years ago.
East West Pro Drummer - Mediocre sounds, awful kicks, interface is a fiddle, good loop library, expensive.